Ready To Remodel Your Home? Is It Better To Build Up Or Out?

Credit: amixstudio / Adobe Stock

For many reasons, including those low mortgage rates that smart buyers grabbed when they hovered around 3%, many families have decided to stay in their current home much longer than they did a decade ago. Real estate research firms such as Redfin note that the average homeowners are still looking at those same four walls for about 13 years. 

This “sheltering in place” can lead to things feeling a little confined. Why? Young families tend to grow, not shrink. Plus, what happens when a recent college grad needs some time to get his/her gig together, or grandma wants to enjoy her grandkids…every day? What if the home happens to be located in an historically zoned neighborhood

That’s right. Talk of remodeling starts working its way into dinner conversation and an important question lands on the table: Are we building up or out? 

What This Means for You — Home remodeling projects can be the most irritating and expensive activities any family can endure. However, a better place to live can be the result.  The decision about whether to build a second-floor addition or expand the ground floor space may seem a tough road, so before taking this trip, please read this post.

Acme is more than just brick. Home improvement products – from kitchen tile to state-of-the-art steel siding – are available to make any remodeling project epic. Click here for great ideas!

First Things First – What’s the Problem You’re Fixing?

As your savvy aunt or sweet mother no doubt told you when you were a teenager trying to decide on what to do about some monumental question (e.g. breakup with a current significant other or give them one more chance?); the first step is to “make a list.” This time-honored strategy also works with remodeling. An honest evaluation of “why” this remodeling is being considered is in order.

Sometimes love for your home means outgrowing your kitchen. Credit: AnnaStills / Adobe Stock

  • Is the kitchen tiny, old and antiquated?
  • Is a shared bathroom causing everyone involved to be late for work or school?
  • What about the bedroom situation? 
  • How about building a cooler entertainment space?
  • What are the HOA rules and/or local building codes for remodeling?
  • What is the size of the home’s lot? Is there any room to expand the ground floor?
  • If you’re a “baby boomer” and thinking about opening up your home to a roommate, what does this require in a remodel?  
  • How can multiple generations live under one roof, in peace and harmony?

Once the “wants and needs” are established, it’s time to move on to the trickiest question: Are we building up or out? As with most things in life, this decision is relative to one’s situation. As some wise person once opined, “it depends.” 

It’s not necessarily better to build up or out. Renovation experts – architects and contractors – note that building out is often simpler and less disruptive (fewer structural changes), while building up saves yard space and can be cost-effective if the home’s foundation supports it. However, this approach involves complex roofing, stairs, and potential structural reinforcement. This makes the process riskier and potentially more costly if the structure isn’t ready. 

The best choice depends on yard size, budget, house structure, zoning, and desired layout. Thus, building OUT may be simpler and building UP saves more space but is more complex. 

Simple, right?

The Pros and Cons of Building Out

This ground-level addition connects directly to the main home. Credit: Susan/ Adobe Stock

Remodeling experts have hundreds, if not thousands of options on expanding a residential space horizontally. Taking the list of “wants and needs” to a planning meeting with an architect and/or building contractor is a good first step in this process.

In general, there are several advantages and disadvantages of building out:

Pros:

  • It is often cheaper & faster (less structural work, no new staircase).
  • It is less disruptive to daily life because of its easier integration.
  • Building out might be better for expanding the kitchen and living area. 
  • It preserves long-term accessibility; stairs can be a major drawback later.

Cons:

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Building Up

This second-story addition rises to meet the home’s growing needs while preserving the original footprint. Acme Brick matched the original brick (also from Acme) to ensure a seamless addition. Credit: Blane Ladymon, AIA

Adding another story on an existing home requires adequate foundation and framing to support the new space. This is a critical engineering consideration and must be determined by an appropriate professional – architect or structural engineer. 

In general, here are the pros and cons of building up:

Pros:

  • This approach requires less yard space and is ideal for small lots.
  • Building up is great for adding bedrooms.
  • Can significantly increase home value and add multiple rooms (bedrooms, baths).

Cons:

  • This requires major structural assessment (foundation and walls must support weight).
  • It requires complex roof work and adding a staircase, adding significant cost and time.
  • There is a higher potential for unexpected structural issues and major change orders.  

New Construction Materials for Home Renovations

Quality Edge TruCedar Board & Batten from Acme Brick Tile & Stone gives this remodeled home’s second story timeless curb appeal. Credit: CBA Culture Marketing

Whether the remodel is to be horizontal or vertical expansion, there are many new options for building materials that were likely not available when the home was originally built. Advances in technology have led to exterior building materials that are stronger, more durable, more climate resistant and (in many cases) weighing less than the original exterior products. When these new materials are chosen to match or aesthetically enhance the existing structure, the renovation can dramatically improve the entire structure.

For example, if a home is constructed of traditional brick, complementary thin brick for the renovated exterior is much less expensive and much easier to install due to its lower weight. Click here to see the vast array of thin brick available from Acme.

Just a few of the many thin brick options available at Acme Brick Tile & Stone. From left: King Klinker in Black Onyx, Cherokee in Old Savannah, and Acme’s glazed Fusion.

No product category has so fundamentally changed the way exteriors have improved than wood-grained metal siding. These products are durable, resistant to sun and weather and have innovative installation systems that are ideal for renovation projects.

Take a look at the metal siding products available from Acme:

Let the Reno Begin!

Taking on a home remodel of any size can be challenging. However, it can also bring the family closer together. Who doesn’t enjoy camping out with no kitchen or bathroom for a month or two? Seriously, the benefits of a larger, more functional living space will be worth it, in the long run.

Whether the renovation project involves horizontal or vertical expansion, it is always best to consult an architect and structural engineer to assess your home’s feasibility for both options. When this is done, the scope of design and work plans can be formulated, and a great new space can be enjoyed for another decade or more.

For your next renovation project, ask your architect or contractor about options with brick and steel siding. Just click here and speak with an expert.

Discover a world of inspiration and find everything you need to bring your vision to life.

If you're embarking on building a new home or crafting a special project, Brick.com has everything you need to bring your vision to life.

Share this Article:

Facebook
X (formerly Twitter)
Pinterest

Need More news? Here’s more

Find a Local Store

Your current location

Select a Dealer

Filter

Manufacturer
Select Manufacturer
Brick Manufacturer
Plant Locations
Select Plant
Filter on Plant Location
Brick SIZE
Select Size
Brick Size Filter
Color
Select Color
Brick Color Filter
Texture
Select Texture
Brick Texture Filter
Manufacturer
Select Manufacturer
Tile Manufacturer
Application
Select Application
Tile Application Filter
Color
Select Color
Tile Color Filter
Material
Select Material
Tile Material Filter
Commercial or Residential
Select Commercial or Residential
Commercial or Residential Filter
No Hardwood Filters
No Luxury Vinyl Filters
No Laminate Filters
Manufacturer
Select Manufacturer
Cladding Manufacturer
Color
Select Color
Cladding Colors
No Paver Filters
No MISC Filters
Manufacturer
Select Manufacturer
Thin Brick MFG
Brick SIZE
Select Size
Thin Brick Sizes
Color
Select Color
Brick Color Filter
Texture
Select Texture
Brick Texture Filter
Manufacturer
Select Manufacturer
Stone MFG
Color
Select Color
Stone Colors